Fashionista's attention has been drawn by Vicki Day of Pure Sauce to a growing desire in the UK for replicating the model of sites such as RetailDish.com, a US site which encourages fashion designers and sales reps to post details of which retail stores they have done good and bad business with. Some of the comments can get pretty catty indeed. One particularly choice example reads along the lines of alleging that "X should be locked up in jail or fed to the Hawaiian SHARKS...this woman is a criminal". No mincing words there then!
But is it legal to have such a website in the UK? Isn't this just an invitation for nightmare defamation claims?
The laws in the UK don't prevent sites from allowing posters to upload comments per se and such sites certainly can be very popular. Think for example of the success of electronic goods or restaurant review sites or even blogs which invite viewer responses. It is also worth remembering that there are potential defences to a defamation claim such as truth (although proving this may be another matter).
However things can certainly go wrong. Posts can be made which are defamatory or unlawful in other respects such as infringing of intellectual property rights. Whilst the poster is unlikely to be able to rest easy (and even the mask of anonymity won't help if a court order can require the website to disclose the poster's details) a website may still be able to find some protection in the UK provided it treads carefully and has done its homework. A website may, for example, be able to rely on defences in Electronic Commerce Regulations where it is only hosting such information and has not monitored, amended or had notice of the unlawful content. It is a tricky area however and much care is needed in the design of a website in order to understand the risks and ensure that it is set up and managed in a defence-friendly manner. It will also be essential to respond to complaints and take down content which is the subject of such complaints as soon as possible.
An alternative option is to monitor and amend content to ensure that it is toned down and no longer unlawful but this can be very risky if something is missed. Fashionista also thinks this can rather spoil the freedom of speech and spontaneous gossip fun of it all which attracts readers in the first place....